4 Types of Non-profit Organizations and How to Choose the Right One

Starting a Business
Saurav Neupane
CPA

You have a goal in mind and have decided that starting a non-profit business gives you the best platform to achieve it. The big question now is, what kind of non-profit organization structure are you going to choose? The one you select should be best suited to help you pursue your non-profit goals.

Use this guide to understand what a non-profit is, its benefits (including tax-exempt status), and what to do once you're ready to launch.

 

Key Takeaways

501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code is the most common type of non-profit, granting tax-exempt status to religious, educational, charitable, scientific, and literary organizations.

Non-profit mission categories focus on advancing the public good (helping the poor, educational advancements, human and animal welfare)

There are several 501(c) subsections, including 501(c)(4) for social welfare groups and 501(c)(5) for labor unions.

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) classifies every new 501(c)(3) as a private foundation until it meets the appropriate thresholds to become a public charity.

While non-profit corporations are common, non-stock corporations, charitable trusts, and unincorporated associations are options.

What is a Non-profit Business?

A non-profit business entity is a business organized to serve the public good. While profit is the primary goal and measure of success for conventional companies, non-profits aim to create a shared benefit for society, whether locally, nationally, or internationally.

Instead of distributing excess profits to owners or shareholders, non-profit structures use all profits to further their mission. Non-profits can earn income, but they can't distribute profits.

In the United States, non-profits register at the state level, are reviewed by the IRS, and are regulated under the IRS tax code, which sets strict, specific requirements for non-profits.

Benefits of operating as a non-profit include:

  • They can qualify for tax-exempt status

  • Private donations to some qualifying non-profits are tax-deductible

  • Some non-profits can qualify for public or private grants

  • A non-profit structure is a separate business entity that can protect founders from liability

  • An organized non-profit is built to outlast any one individual's involvement

Non-profit vs. Not-for-Profit vs. Charity

Non-profit, not-for-profit, and charities are sometimes used interchangeably, but they're distinct.

Non-profit (state-chartered credit unions, veterans organizations, federal credit unions) refers to the broad legal and tax category; a charity usually indicates 501(c)(3) public charity status; and not-for-profit (domestic fraternal societies) is often used when referring to mutual benefit groups like clubs and associations.

Understanding these differences will help as you develop your idea.

Tax Exempt Status

Non-profits that meet specific legal requirements can apply for tax-exempt status via a separate IRS filing, which frees them from most tax obligations at the federal and state levels. This means no state or federal income tax on profits.

Maintaining this status requires complying with IRS regulations concerning non-profit taxes and reporting non-profit finances yearly on an informational tax return, IRS Form 990, Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax.

What are the Different Types of Non-profit Organizations?

The most common non-profit organization is a 501(c)(3), named for the section of the IRS code under which it's established. A 501(c)(3) is a non-profit created for a social purpose, which the IRS states can be charitable, religious, educational, scientific, literary, testing for public safety, fostering national or international amateur sports competition, or preventing cruelty to children or animals.

Mission categories you'll see in practice

Most 501(c)(3) organizations can be subdivided into public charities or private foundations. Public charities are supported by the public and receive funding for their work from various sources. Private foundations depend on accumulated private wealth and more often finance other charitable organizations. New 501(c)(3) organizations are private foundations by default until they demonstrate broad public or governmental support.

Common mission categories include religious, educational, health and medical, social services, arts and culture, environmental, and advocacy organizations.

Political organizations under Section 527

The 501(c)(3) may be the most common, but many types of organizations are established under IRS code section 501. You can find more details under IRS publication 557.

Subsection

Who it's for

Donations deductible?

501(c)(4)

Civic leagues or local employee associations

No

501(c)(5)

Labor unions or agricultural organizations

No (dues and business-related assessments may be deductible)

501(c)(6)

Chambers of commerce and other leagues or boards improving business conditions

No (dues/contributions may be deductible)

501(c)(7)

Social clubs for recreational purposes

No (dues, initiation fees, and assessments may be deductible)

501(c)(15)

Mutual insurance companies

No

What Non-profits Can't Do With Their Money

Private inurement and self-dealing govern what non-profits can do with their money, especially when it comes to insiders. No profits can be distributed to members, insiders, or political campaigns; employee salaries must be reasonable compared to other roles, and non-profit assets are tied to the mission.

Bylaws and a board of directors serve as the governance backstop. The bylaws establish the binding legal rules, while the board acts as the active enforcement mechanism. Together, they form a safety net for the organization. Bookkeeping for non-profits helps board members keep track throughout the tax year.

What are the Different Business Structures Available for My Charity?

Deciding how you will organize your non-profit is critical. Several types of non-profit organization structures exist, each with benefits and downsides. We also highlight two structures commonly confused with non-profits.

Unincorporated Association

An association is the most informal structure for a charity because all you need is an established structure and a group of people with a shared purpose. Associations are simple and easy because they don't require extra paperwork, but they're limited in what they can do.

You can meet with like-minded people, plan activities, and even open a bank account to help pay association-related expenses. But you can't accept tax-deductible donations or qualify for tax-exempt status. An unincorporated association does not protect your personal assets from financial risk.

Trust

Another structure to consider is a charitable trust, which provides a legal structure to manage a collection of assets. Trusts qualifying for 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status usually function as private foundations, offering grants to fund other charities doing specific work.

Trusts help non-profits manage a large estate or endowment, but they're not very flexible. They must follow stringent regulations, and like an unincorporated association, they do not protect owners from legal liability.

Corporation

Most non-profit 501(c)(3) organizations are structured as corporations, creating a separate legal entity and protecting owners and members from legal liability for the company's work. Having a corporate structure also makes it much easier to apply for tax-exempt status and qualify for grants and tax-deductible donations.

The downside is that it comes with many regulations and official procedures a non-profit must follow, and a corporation is not the most flexible business entity.

Many different non-profits under IRS Section 501 are frequently organized as corporations, but 501(c)(3) is the most common and versatile.

LLC

A limited liability company, or LLC, is a flexible business entity many small businesses use to protect their assets and save on income taxes while retaining significant control over business operations.

LLCs can apply for non-profit status, but it's complex and somewhat rare. Normal small business LLCs can be made up of one or more individuals. However, to become a non-profit LLC, every member must be a tax-exempt organization.

Non-profit LLCs are generally formed only when a group of non-profit corporations needs to start an umbrella organization to complete a task together.

Benefit corporation

A benefit corporation, often called a public benefit corporation, is a for-profit entity that legally balances its mission to create positive social or environmental impact with an additional requirement to generate financial profit for its shareholders.

The mission and altruistic focus sound like a non-profit, but the profit motive and financial distribution confirm that it's not.

Cooperative

Cooperatives, or co-ops, are businesses owned, controlled, and operated for the mutual benefit of the people who use its services, work there, or buy from it.

Because the focus isn't on maximizing profits for outside investors, like with cooperative hospital service organizations, some confuse co-ops with non-profits, but they aren't. Cooperative service organizations operate to provide goods, services, or better economic conditions at or near cost, and any financial surplus is returned to members based on how much they use the business. This is often called a patronage refund or dividend.

Do I Need to Incorporate My Non-profit?

If you are pooling funds and working with your neighbors or coworkers to meet your community's needs, you may not need to incorporate your non-profit. A group of parents does not need to become a corporation to share their money and put on activities for students, but corporate status would protect them from legal liability.

If you set your sights on anything more ambitious or wider-reaching for your non-profit, however, you should seriously consider incorporation. The legal structure of a non-profit allows it to carry on its work without depending on an individual to make it happen.

Once your non-profit takes on that corporate structure, it becomes much easier to qualify for tax-exempt status, apply for grants, and hire staff. This status signals legitimacy.

Ready to Start Your Non-profit Business?

Choosing the right structure for your non-profit matters, and taking the next step to make it official is just as critical. While you can do it yourself, professional entity formation support ensures the process is handled accurately and efficiently the first time.

If you're ready to focus on your organization while the taxes and bookkeeping are done for you, talk to the non-profit experts at 1-800Accountant today to establish the best way forward.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a non-profit make money by selling products and services?

Yes, a non-profit can legally make money by selling products and services to fund its operations. If the revenue comes from activities directly related to its exempt purpose, the income is generally tax-free. However, if the sales come from unrelated business activities, the profits are subject to the Unrelated Business Income Tax.

What's the difference between a non-profit and a charity?

While sometimes used interchangeably, they are different. A non-profit is a broad legal category for organizations that do not distribute profits to owners. A charity, by contrast, is a specific type of non-profit focused on public benefit. All charities are non-profits, but not all non-profits qualify as charities. Non-profits can include social clubs or business leagues, while charities must specifically serve religious, educational, charitable, or scientific purposes.

What is a 501(c)(3), and how is it different from other non-profit types?

A 501(c)(3) is a specific IRS tax-exempt organization type reserved for religious, educational, charitable, scientific, and literary organizations. Unlike other non-profits, donations made to a 501(c)(3) organization are fully tax-deductible for the donors. Other non-profit types enjoy tax exemption on earnings but cannot offer donor tax deductions.

What happens to a non-profit's assets and money if it shuts down?

When a non-profit shuts down, it is prohibited from distributing its remaining assets or cash to its founders, board members, or employees. The organization must first pay off all outstanding debts and liabilities. Any remaining funds must be transferred to another tax-exempt non-profit organization or a government entity.

What are the rules on self-dealing and private benefit to insiders?

Strict federal and state laws prohibit non-profit insiders from using the organization’s assets for personal financial gain or private benefit. Board members and executives cannot approve transactions that provide them with above-market financial advantages, a restriction known as private inurement. Violating these self-dealing rules can result in severe IRS penalties, excise taxes, and the loss of the organization's tax-exempt status.

What kinds of organizations besides charities can be non-profits?

Beyond traditional charities, many other entity types operate under non-profit structures to serve specific group interests rather than the general public. These include civic leagues, social welfare organizations, local chambers of commerce, and professional business leagues. Recreational social clubs, fraternal societies, labor unions, and agricultural organizations regularly qualify for non-profit status.

This post is to be used for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, business, or tax advice. Each person should consult his or her own attorney, business advisor, or tax advisor with respect to matters referenced in this post. 1‑800Accountant assumes no liability for actions taken in reliance upon the information contained herein.